Theory CSP_T_law_ref

Up to index of Isabelle/HOL/HOL-Complex/CSP/CSP_T

theory CSP_T_law_ref
imports CSP_T_law_basic
begin

           (*-------------------------------------------*
            |        CSP-Prover on Isabelle2004         |
            |               December 2004               |
            |                   June 2005  (modified)   |
            |              September 2005  (modified)   |
            |                                           |
            |        CSP-Prover on Isabelle2005         |
            |                October 2005  (modified)   |
            |                  March 2007  (modified)   |
            |                                           |
            |        Yoshinao Isobe (AIST JAPAN)        |
            *-------------------------------------------*)

theory CSP_T_law_ref
imports CSP_T_law_basic
begin

(*****************************************************************

         1. rules for refinement

 *****************************************************************)

(*-------------------------------------------------------*
 |              decompose Internal choice                |
 *-------------------------------------------------------*)

(*** or <= ***)                                         (* unsafe *)

lemma cspT_Int_choice_left1:
  "P1 <=T[M1,M2] Q ==> P1 |~| P2 <=T[M1,M2] Q"
apply (simp add: cspT_semantics)
apply (rule, simp add: in_traces)
apply (force)
done

lemma cspT_Int_choice_left2:
  "P2 <=T[M1,M2] Q ==> P1 |~| P2 <=T[M1,M2] Q"
apply (rule cspT_rw_left)
apply (rule cspT_commut)
by (simp add: cspT_Int_choice_left1)

(*** <= and ***)                                          (* safe *)

lemma cspT_Int_choice_right:
  "[| P <=T[M1,M2] Q1 ; P <=T[M1,M2] Q2 |]
      ==> P <=T[M1,M2] Q1 |~| Q2"
apply (simp add: cspT_semantics)
apply (rule, simp add: in_traces)
apply (force)
done

(*-------------------------------------------------------*
 |        decompose Replicated internal choice           |
 *-------------------------------------------------------*)

(*** EX <= ***)                                           (* unsafe *)

lemma cspT_Rep_int_choice_nat_left:
  "(EX n. n:N & Pf n <=T[M1,M2] Q)
      ==> !nat :N .. Pf <=T[M1,M2] Q"
apply (simp add: cspT_semantics)
apply (rule, simp add: in_traces)
apply (force)
done

lemma cspT_Rep_int_choice_nat_left_x:
  "[| n:N ; Pf n <=T[M1,M2] Q |]
  ==> !nat :N .. Pf <=T[M1,M2] Q"
apply (rule cspT_Rep_int_choice_nat_left)
by (fast)

lemma cspT_Rep_int_choice_set_left:
  "(EX X. X:Xs & Pf X <=T[M1,M2] Q)
      ==> !set :Xs .. Pf <=T[M1,M2] Q"
apply (simp add: cspT_semantics)
apply (rule, simp add: in_traces)
apply (force)
done

lemma cspT_Rep_int_choice_set_left_x:
  "[| X:Xs ; Pf X <=T[M1,M2] Q |]
  ==> !set :Xs .. Pf <=T[M1,M2] Q"
apply (rule cspT_Rep_int_choice_set_left)
by (fast)

lemma cspT_Rep_int_choice_com_left:
  "(EX a. a:X & Pf a <=T[M1,M2] Q)
      ==> ! :X .. Pf <=T[M1,M2] Q"
apply (simp add: cspT_semantics)
apply (rule, simp add: in_traces)
apply (force)
done

lemma cspT_Rep_int_choice_com_left_x:
  "[| a:X ; Pf a <=T[M1,M2] Q |]
  ==> ! :X .. Pf <=T[M1,M2] Q"
apply (rule cspT_Rep_int_choice_com_left)
by (fast)

lemma cspT_Rep_int_choice_f_left:
  "[| inj f ; (EX a. a:X & Pf a <=T[M1,M2] Q) |]
      ==> !<f> :X .. Pf <=T[M1,M2] Q"
apply (simp add: cspT_semantics)
apply (rule, simp add: in_traces)
apply (force)
done

lemma cspT_Rep_int_choice_f_left_x:
  "[| inj f ; a:X ; Pf a <=T[M1,M2] Q |]
  ==> !<f> :X .. Pf <=T[M1,M2] Q"
apply (rule cspT_Rep_int_choice_f_left)
apply (simp)
by (fast)

lemmas cspT_Rep_int_choice_left = cspT_Rep_int_choice_nat_left
                                  cspT_Rep_int_choice_set_left
                                  cspT_Rep_int_choice_com_left
                                  cspT_Rep_int_choice_f_left

lemmas cspT_Rep_int_choice_left_x = cspT_Rep_int_choice_nat_left_x
                                  cspT_Rep_int_choice_set_left_x
                                  cspT_Rep_int_choice_com_left_x
                                  cspT_Rep_int_choice_f_left_x

(*** <= ALL ***)                                         (* safe *)

lemma cspT_Rep_int_choice_nat_right:
  "[| !!n. n:N ==> P <=T[M1,M2] Qf n |]
               ==> P <=T[M1,M2] !nat :N .. Qf"
apply (simp add: cspT_semantics)
apply (rule, simp add: in_traces)
apply (force)
done

lemma cspT_Rep_int_choice_set_right:
  "[| !!X. X:Xs ==> P <=T[M1,M2] Qf X |]
               ==> P <=T[M1,M2] !set :Xs .. Qf"
apply (simp add: cspT_semantics)
apply (rule, simp add: in_traces)
apply (force)
done

lemma cspT_Rep_int_choice_com_right:
  "[| !!a. a:X ==> P <=T[M1,M2] Qf a |]
               ==> P <=T[M1,M2] ! :X .. Qf"
apply (simp add: cspT_semantics)
apply (rule, simp add: in_traces)
apply (force)
done

lemma cspT_Rep_int_choice_f_right:
  "[| inj f ; !!a. a:X ==> P <=T[M1,M2] Qf a |]
               ==> P <=T[M1,M2] !<f> :X .. Qf"
apply (simp add: cspT_semantics)
apply (rule, simp add: in_traces)
apply (force)
done

lemmas cspT_Rep_int_choice_right 
     = cspT_Rep_int_choice_nat_right
       cspT_Rep_int_choice_set_right
       cspT_Rep_int_choice_com_right
       cspT_Rep_int_choice_f_right

(* 1,2,3,f E *)

lemma cspT_Rep_int_choice_nat_rightE:
  "[| P <=T[M1,M2] !nat :N .. Qf ;
      ALL n:N. P <=T[M1,M2] Qf n ==> R
   |] ==> R"
apply (simp add: cspT_semantics)
apply (simp add: subdomT_iff)
apply (simp add: in_traces)
apply (force)
done

lemma cspT_Rep_int_choice_set_rightE:
  "[| P <=T[M1,M2] !set :Xs .. Qf ;
      ALL X:Xs. P <=T[M1,M2] Qf X ==> R
   |] ==> R"
apply (simp add: cspT_semantics)
apply (simp add: subdomT_iff)
apply (simp add: in_traces)
apply (force)
done

lemma cspT_Rep_int_choice_com_rightE:
  "[| P <=T[M1,M2] ! :X .. Qf ;
      ALL a:X. P <=T[M1,M2] Qf a ==> R
   |] ==> R"
apply (simp add: cspT_semantics)
apply (simp add: subdomT_iff)
apply (simp add: in_traces)
apply (force)
done

lemma cspT_Rep_int_choice_f_rightE:
  "[| P <=T[M1,M2] !<f> :X .. Qf ; inj f ;
      [| ALL a:X. P <=T[M1,M2] Qf a |] ==> R
   |] ==> R"
apply (simp add: cspT_semantics)
apply (simp add: subdomT_iff)
apply (simp add: in_traces)
apply (force)
done

lemmas cspT_Rep_int_choice_rightE =
       cspT_Rep_int_choice_nat_rightE
       cspT_Rep_int_choice_set_rightE
       cspT_Rep_int_choice_com_rightE
       cspT_Rep_int_choice_f_rightE

(*-------------------------------------------------------*
 |             decomposition with subset                 |
 *-------------------------------------------------------*)

(*** Rep_int_choice ***)                                        (* unsafe *)

lemma cspT_Rep_int_choice_nat_subset:
  "[| N2 <= N1  ; !!n. n:N2 ==> Pf n <=T[M1,M2] Qf n |]
                    ==> !nat :N1 .. Pf <=T[M1,M2] !nat :N2 .. Qf"
apply (simp add: cspT_semantics)
apply (rule, simp add: in_traces)
apply (force)
done

lemma cspT_Rep_int_choice_set_subset:
  "[| Ys <= Xs  ; !!X. X:Ys ==> Pf X <=T[M1,M2] Qf X |]
                    ==> !set :Xs .. Pf <=T[M1,M2] !set :Ys .. Qf"
apply (simp add: cspT_semantics)
apply (rule, simp add: in_traces)
apply (force)
done

lemma cspT_Rep_int_choice_com_subset:
  "[| Y <= X  ; !!a. a:Y ==> Pf a <=T[M1,M2] Qf a |]
                    ==> ! :X .. Pf <=T[M1,M2] ! :Y .. Qf"
apply (simp add: cspT_semantics)
apply (rule, simp add: in_traces)
apply (force)
done

lemma cspT_Rep_int_choice_f_subset:
  "[| inj f ; Y <= X  ; !!a. a:Y ==> Pf a <=T[M1,M2] Qf a |]
                    ==> !<f> :X .. Pf <=T[M1,M2] !<f> :Y .. Qf"
apply (simp add: cspT_semantics)
apply (rule, simp add: in_traces)
apply (force)
done

lemmas cspT_Rep_int_choice_subset 
     = cspT_Rep_int_choice_nat_subset
       cspT_Rep_int_choice_set_subset
       cspT_Rep_int_choice_com_subset
       cspT_Rep_int_choice_f_subset

(*** ! x:X .. and ? -> ***)

lemma cspT_Int_Ext_pre_choice_subset:
  "[| Y ~={} ; Y <= X ; !!a. a:Y ==> Pf a <=T[M1,M2] Qf a |]
        ==> ! x:X .. (x -> Pf x) <=T[M1,M2]
            ? :Y -> Qf"
apply (simp add: cspT_semantics)
apply (rule, simp add: in_traces)
apply (force)
done

lemmas cspT_decompo_subset = cspT_Rep_int_choice_subset
                             cspT_Int_Ext_pre_choice_subset

(*-------------------------------------------------------*
 |               decompose external choice               |
 *-------------------------------------------------------*)

lemma cspT_Ext_choice_right:
  "[| P <=T[M1,M2] Q1 ;
      P <=T[M1,M2] Q2 |]
      ==> P <=T[M1,M2] Q1 [+] Q2"
apply (simp add: cspT_semantics)
apply (rule, simp add: in_traces)
apply (force)
done

end

lemma cspT_Int_choice_left1:

  P1.0 <=T[M1.0,M2.0] Q ==> P1.0 |~| P2.0 <=T[M1.0,M2.0] Q

lemma cspT_Int_choice_left2:

  P2.0 <=T[M1.0,M2.0] Q ==> P1.0 |~| P2.0 <=T[M1.0,M2.0] Q

lemma cspT_Int_choice_right:

  [| P <=T[M1.0,M2.0] Q1.0; P <=T[M1.0,M2.0] Q2.0 |]
  ==> P <=T[M1.0,M2.0] Q1.0 |~| Q2.0

lemma cspT_Rep_int_choice_nat_left:

n. nNPf n <=T[M1.0,M2.0] Q ==> !nat :N .. Pf <=T[M1.0,M2.0] Q

lemma cspT_Rep_int_choice_nat_left_x:

  [| nN; Pf n <=T[M1.0,M2.0] Q |] ==> !nat :N .. Pf <=T[M1.0,M2.0] Q

lemma cspT_Rep_int_choice_set_left:

X. XXsPf X <=T[M1.0,M2.0] Q ==> !set :Xs .. Pf <=T[M1.0,M2.0] Q

lemma cspT_Rep_int_choice_set_left_x:

  [| XXs; Pf X <=T[M1.0,M2.0] Q |] ==> !set :Xs .. Pf <=T[M1.0,M2.0] Q

lemma cspT_Rep_int_choice_com_left:

a. aXPf a <=T[M1.0,M2.0] Q ==> ! :X .. Pf <=T[M1.0,M2.0] Q

lemma cspT_Rep_int_choice_com_left_x:

  [| aX; Pf a <=T[M1.0,M2.0] Q |] ==> ! :X .. Pf <=T[M1.0,M2.0] Q

lemma cspT_Rep_int_choice_f_left:

  [| inj f; ∃a. aXPf a <=T[M1.0,M2.0] Q |]
  ==> !<f> :X .. Pf <=T[M1.0,M2.0] Q

lemma cspT_Rep_int_choice_f_left_x:

  [| inj f; aX; Pf a <=T[M1.0,M2.0] Q |] ==> !<f> :X .. Pf <=T[M1.0,M2.0] Q

lemmas cspT_Rep_int_choice_left:

n. nNPf n <=T[M1.0,M2.0] Q ==> !nat :N .. Pf <=T[M1.0,M2.0] Q
X. XXsPf X <=T[M1.0,M2.0] Q ==> !set :Xs .. Pf <=T[M1.0,M2.0] Q
a. aXPf a <=T[M1.0,M2.0] Q ==> ! :X .. Pf <=T[M1.0,M2.0] Q
  [| inj f; ∃a. aXPf a <=T[M1.0,M2.0] Q |]
  ==> !<f> :X .. Pf <=T[M1.0,M2.0] Q

lemmas cspT_Rep_int_choice_left:

n. nNPf n <=T[M1.0,M2.0] Q ==> !nat :N .. Pf <=T[M1.0,M2.0] Q
X. XXsPf X <=T[M1.0,M2.0] Q ==> !set :Xs .. Pf <=T[M1.0,M2.0] Q
a. aXPf a <=T[M1.0,M2.0] Q ==> ! :X .. Pf <=T[M1.0,M2.0] Q
  [| inj f; ∃a. aXPf a <=T[M1.0,M2.0] Q |]
  ==> !<f> :X .. Pf <=T[M1.0,M2.0] Q

lemmas cspT_Rep_int_choice_left_x:

  [| nN; Pf n <=T[M1.0,M2.0] Q |] ==> !nat :N .. Pf <=T[M1.0,M2.0] Q
  [| XXs; Pf X <=T[M1.0,M2.0] Q |] ==> !set :Xs .. Pf <=T[M1.0,M2.0] Q
  [| aX; Pf a <=T[M1.0,M2.0] Q |] ==> ! :X .. Pf <=T[M1.0,M2.0] Q
  [| inj f; aX; Pf a <=T[M1.0,M2.0] Q |] ==> !<f> :X .. Pf <=T[M1.0,M2.0] Q

lemmas cspT_Rep_int_choice_left_x:

  [| nN; Pf n <=T[M1.0,M2.0] Q |] ==> !nat :N .. Pf <=T[M1.0,M2.0] Q
  [| XXs; Pf X <=T[M1.0,M2.0] Q |] ==> !set :Xs .. Pf <=T[M1.0,M2.0] Q
  [| aX; Pf a <=T[M1.0,M2.0] Q |] ==> ! :X .. Pf <=T[M1.0,M2.0] Q
  [| inj f; aX; Pf a <=T[M1.0,M2.0] Q |] ==> !<f> :X .. Pf <=T[M1.0,M2.0] Q

lemma cspT_Rep_int_choice_nat_right:

  (!!n. nN ==> P <=T[M1.0,M2.0] Qf n) ==> P <=T[M1.0,M2.0] !nat :N .. Qf

lemma cspT_Rep_int_choice_set_right:

  (!!X. XXs ==> P <=T[M1.0,M2.0] Qf X) ==> P <=T[M1.0,M2.0] !set :Xs .. Qf

lemma cspT_Rep_int_choice_com_right:

  (!!a. aX ==> P <=T[M1.0,M2.0] Qf a) ==> P <=T[M1.0,M2.0] ! :X .. Qf

lemma cspT_Rep_int_choice_f_right:

  [| inj f; !!a. aX ==> P <=T[M1.0,M2.0] Qf a |]
  ==> P <=T[M1.0,M2.0] !<f> :X .. Qf

lemmas cspT_Rep_int_choice_right:

  (!!n. nN ==> P <=T[M1.0,M2.0] Qf n) ==> P <=T[M1.0,M2.0] !nat :N .. Qf
  (!!X. XXs ==> P <=T[M1.0,M2.0] Qf X) ==> P <=T[M1.0,M2.0] !set :Xs .. Qf
  (!!a. aX ==> P <=T[M1.0,M2.0] Qf a) ==> P <=T[M1.0,M2.0] ! :X .. Qf
  [| inj f; !!a. aX ==> P <=T[M1.0,M2.0] Qf a |]
  ==> P <=T[M1.0,M2.0] !<f> :X .. Qf

lemmas cspT_Rep_int_choice_right:

  (!!n. nN ==> P <=T[M1.0,M2.0] Qf n) ==> P <=T[M1.0,M2.0] !nat :N .. Qf
  (!!X. XXs ==> P <=T[M1.0,M2.0] Qf X) ==> P <=T[M1.0,M2.0] !set :Xs .. Qf
  (!!a. aX ==> P <=T[M1.0,M2.0] Qf a) ==> P <=T[M1.0,M2.0] ! :X .. Qf
  [| inj f; !!a. aX ==> P <=T[M1.0,M2.0] Qf a |]
  ==> P <=T[M1.0,M2.0] !<f> :X .. Qf

lemma cspT_Rep_int_choice_nat_rightE:

  [| P <=T[M1.0,M2.0] !nat :N .. Qf; ∀nN. P <=T[M1.0,M2.0] Qf n ==> R |] ==> R

lemma cspT_Rep_int_choice_set_rightE:

  [| P <=T[M1.0,M2.0] !set :Xs .. Qf; ∀XXs. P <=T[M1.0,M2.0] Qf X ==> R |] ==> R

lemma cspT_Rep_int_choice_com_rightE:

  [| P <=T[M1.0,M2.0] ! :X .. Qf; ∀aX. P <=T[M1.0,M2.0] Qf a ==> R |] ==> R

lemma cspT_Rep_int_choice_f_rightE:

  [| P <=T[M1.0,M2.0] !<f> :X .. Qf; inj f; ∀aX. P <=T[M1.0,M2.0] Qf a ==> R |]
  ==> R

lemmas cspT_Rep_int_choice_rightE:

  [| P <=T[M1.0,M2.0] !nat :N .. Qf; ∀nN. P <=T[M1.0,M2.0] Qf n ==> R |] ==> R
  [| P <=T[M1.0,M2.0] !set :Xs .. Qf; ∀XXs. P <=T[M1.0,M2.0] Qf X ==> R |] ==> R
  [| P <=T[M1.0,M2.0] ! :X .. Qf; ∀aX. P <=T[M1.0,M2.0] Qf a ==> R |] ==> R
  [| P <=T[M1.0,M2.0] !<f> :X .. Qf; inj f; ∀aX. P <=T[M1.0,M2.0] Qf a ==> R |]
  ==> R

lemmas cspT_Rep_int_choice_rightE:

  [| P <=T[M1.0,M2.0] !nat :N .. Qf; ∀nN. P <=T[M1.0,M2.0] Qf n ==> R |] ==> R
  [| P <=T[M1.0,M2.0] !set :Xs .. Qf; ∀XXs. P <=T[M1.0,M2.0] Qf X ==> R |] ==> R
  [| P <=T[M1.0,M2.0] ! :X .. Qf; ∀aX. P <=T[M1.0,M2.0] Qf a ==> R |] ==> R
  [| P <=T[M1.0,M2.0] !<f> :X .. Qf; inj f; ∀aX. P <=T[M1.0,M2.0] Qf a ==> R |]
  ==> R

lemma cspT_Rep_int_choice_nat_subset:

  [| N2.0N1.0; !!n. nN2.0 ==> Pf n <=T[M1.0,M2.0] Qf n |]
  ==> !nat :N1.0 .. Pf <=T[M1.0,M2.0] !nat :N2.0 .. Qf

lemma cspT_Rep_int_choice_set_subset:

  [| YsXs; !!X. XYs ==> Pf X <=T[M1.0,M2.0] Qf X |]
  ==> !set :Xs .. Pf <=T[M1.0,M2.0] !set :Ys .. Qf

lemma cspT_Rep_int_choice_com_subset:

  [| YX; !!a. aY ==> Pf a <=T[M1.0,M2.0] Qf a |]
  ==> ! :X .. Pf <=T[M1.0,M2.0] ! :Y .. Qf

lemma cspT_Rep_int_choice_f_subset:

  [| inj f; YX; !!a. aY ==> Pf a <=T[M1.0,M2.0] Qf a |]
  ==> !<f> :X .. Pf <=T[M1.0,M2.0] !<f> :Y .. Qf

lemmas cspT_Rep_int_choice_subset:

  [| N2.0N1.0; !!n. nN2.0 ==> Pf n <=T[M1.0,M2.0] Qf n |]
  ==> !nat :N1.0 .. Pf <=T[M1.0,M2.0] !nat :N2.0 .. Qf
  [| YsXs; !!X. XYs ==> Pf X <=T[M1.0,M2.0] Qf X |]
  ==> !set :Xs .. Pf <=T[M1.0,M2.0] !set :Ys .. Qf
  [| YX; !!a. aY ==> Pf a <=T[M1.0,M2.0] Qf a |]
  ==> ! :X .. Pf <=T[M1.0,M2.0] ! :Y .. Qf
  [| inj f; YX; !!a. aY ==> Pf a <=T[M1.0,M2.0] Qf a |]
  ==> !<f> :X .. Pf <=T[M1.0,M2.0] !<f> :Y .. Qf

lemmas cspT_Rep_int_choice_subset:

  [| N2.0N1.0; !!n. nN2.0 ==> Pf n <=T[M1.0,M2.0] Qf n |]
  ==> !nat :N1.0 .. Pf <=T[M1.0,M2.0] !nat :N2.0 .. Qf
  [| YsXs; !!X. XYs ==> Pf X <=T[M1.0,M2.0] Qf X |]
  ==> !set :Xs .. Pf <=T[M1.0,M2.0] !set :Ys .. Qf
  [| YX; !!a. aY ==> Pf a <=T[M1.0,M2.0] Qf a |]
  ==> ! :X .. Pf <=T[M1.0,M2.0] ! :Y .. Qf
  [| inj f; YX; !!a. aY ==> Pf a <=T[M1.0,M2.0] Qf a |]
  ==> !<f> :X .. Pf <=T[M1.0,M2.0] !<f> :Y .. Qf

lemma cspT_Int_Ext_pre_choice_subset:

  [| Y ≠ {}; YX; !!a. aY ==> Pf a <=T[M1.0,M2.0] Qf a |]
  ==> ! x:X .. x -> Pf x <=T[M1.0,M2.0] ? :Y -> Qf

lemmas cspT_decompo_subset:

  [| N2.0N1.0; !!n. nN2.0 ==> Pf n <=T[M1.0,M2.0] Qf n |]
  ==> !nat :N1.0 .. Pf <=T[M1.0,M2.0] !nat :N2.0 .. Qf
  [| YsXs; !!X. XYs ==> Pf X <=T[M1.0,M2.0] Qf X |]
  ==> !set :Xs .. Pf <=T[M1.0,M2.0] !set :Ys .. Qf
  [| YX; !!a. aY ==> Pf a <=T[M1.0,M2.0] Qf a |]
  ==> ! :X .. Pf <=T[M1.0,M2.0] ! :Y .. Qf
  [| inj f; YX; !!a. aY ==> Pf a <=T[M1.0,M2.0] Qf a |]
  ==> !<f> :X .. Pf <=T[M1.0,M2.0] !<f> :Y .. Qf
  [| Y ≠ {}; YX; !!a. aY ==> Pf a <=T[M1.0,M2.0] Qf a |]
  ==> ! x:X .. x -> Pf x <=T[M1.0,M2.0] ? :Y -> Qf

lemmas cspT_decompo_subset:

  [| N2.0N1.0; !!n. nN2.0 ==> Pf n <=T[M1.0,M2.0] Qf n |]
  ==> !nat :N1.0 .. Pf <=T[M1.0,M2.0] !nat :N2.0 .. Qf
  [| YsXs; !!X. XYs ==> Pf X <=T[M1.0,M2.0] Qf X |]
  ==> !set :Xs .. Pf <=T[M1.0,M2.0] !set :Ys .. Qf
  [| YX; !!a. aY ==> Pf a <=T[M1.0,M2.0] Qf a |]
  ==> ! :X .. Pf <=T[M1.0,M2.0] ! :Y .. Qf
  [| inj f; YX; !!a. aY ==> Pf a <=T[M1.0,M2.0] Qf a |]
  ==> !<f> :X .. Pf <=T[M1.0,M2.0] !<f> :Y .. Qf
  [| Y ≠ {}; YX; !!a. aY ==> Pf a <=T[M1.0,M2.0] Qf a |]
  ==> ! x:X .. x -> Pf x <=T[M1.0,M2.0] ? :Y -> Qf

lemma cspT_Ext_choice_right:

  [| P <=T[M1.0,M2.0] Q1.0; P <=T[M1.0,M2.0] Q2.0 |]
  ==> P <=T[M1.0,M2.0] Q1.0 [+] Q2.0